Annette Manwell | From the Holland Sentinel | Read the Full Article

Holland — HDR, the firm that recommended that the city of Holland choose combined cycle natural gas for its electrical generation, also could become the engineer for the project.

The Holland City Council will decide Wednesday whether to affirm Monday’s decision by the Holland Board of Public Works Board of Directors to hire the firm at an estimated cost of $2.5 million. The decision was made in December to build a new power plant at a location other than the site of the James DeYoung power plant.

HDR could, if approved by the city council, provide engineering services to the BPW for the design of the new power plant. Services will be billed on a time and materials basis, General Manager Dave Koster said. Although $2.5 million is the estimate, that amount could end up being different. He expected the services provided by HDR will amount to about 1 to 2 percent of the total project cost.

Koster and Business Services Director Dan Nally said much of the overall cost for HDR’s services also would be decided on how much work the firm does to assist with the expansion of the city’s snowmelt system and the district heating component of the Holland Community Energy Plan.

The BPW put out a request for qualifications — a report that helped BPW determine which firm was most qualified to accomplish the job — to seven firms but received only three back. While HDR’s costs were estimated at more than another qualifying company, that company is based in New Jersey and travel expenses were not included. HDR’s Ann Arbor office would be handling the BPW’s engineering needs.

HDR will have team leaders to oversee mechanical, instrumentation, electrical, permitting, architectural and civil and structural aspects of the new plant, said HDR Project Manager Ron Utter.

A timeline for the power plant has not been given because the site has not been chosen, Nally said. The BPW did enter into a closed session meeting Monday to discuss property acquisition. It was not stated if it was concerning the location of the power plant, and no action was taken. The location of the plant also would need city council approval. Once the location is finalized, the necessary equipment will be decided and the air permitting process will begin, Nally said.

The post Holland Sentinel: Holland city officials consider new power plant engineer appeared first on Holland's Energy Future | P21 Decision.

From the Holland Sentinel

Holland —  The city of Holland and its Board of Public Works will move forward with the 114-megawatt combined cycle natural gas power plant.

The post Holland City Council Approves 114 Megawatt Natural Gas Power Plant appeared first on Holland's Energy Future | P21 Decision.

Holland —The commercial wind opportunities mentioned briefly by Holland Board of Public Works officials in recent energy meetings could be coming to fruition.

The BPW Board of Directors will consider Monday at its 4 p.m. regular meeting two commercial wind energy options.

Read the full article

The post Holland Sentinel: Holland Board of Public Works will consider wind energy options appeared first on Holland's Energy Future | P21 Decision.

The post Holland Sentinel with Dan Nally Part 3: Renewable Resources & Conservation appeared first on Holland's Energy Future | P21 Decision.

The post Holland Sentinel with Dan Nally Part 2: Financial Impact appeared first on Holland's Energy Future | P21 Decision.

The post Holland Sentinel with Dan Nally Part 1: Electrical Generation appeared first on Holland's Energy Future | P21 Decision.

You can read them from the links provided here: One was titled “BPW is moving too fast on power plant decision,” and another called “Our energy future is not with fossil fuels.”

While it’s our goal to honor honest, constructive feedback, we don’t want to see facts skewed and misinterpretations confirmed as truth.

“Sneaky”

Both letters insinuate that the Holland BPW has rushed this process through without inviting input. One of the letters opens with this line:

In case you’ve missed it, the city of Holland has sneaked through its proposals and scenario analysis for the new energy plan…

We don’t agree that any piece of this process has been “sneaked through.”  We feel that our commitment to inviting the community into this conversation has been thorough. For over a year, we’ve sent numerous bill inserts to all of our customers with facts and information, we’ve lead dozens of public meetings and purchased significant newspaper, online and radio advertisements to promote them. We’ve built an open, public website (this site) and established a social media presence on Facebook and Twitter specifically dedicated to this process.

“Not Reasonable Estimates”

The letters also asserted several times that the HBPW’s analysis is based on today’s low gas prices:

The BPW based its economic study on current prices ($2.00-$3.00 per thousand cubic feet) for fracking gas, and thus proved to itself that this is the best option….

The BPW should not have based its decision for a 40-year life gas turbine plant on today’s spot price for gas. Fracking gas prices will go up.

The present market looks appealing to investors, yet is fraught with unseen costs. These costs are not reasonable estimates for the 25- to 40- year lifespan of the plant.

Again, we don’t feel this accurately represents the truth. In actuality, we have explained in our public meetings how each scenario involving natural gas factored both high and low estimates of future gas pricing. No one can perfectly predict the future of energy prices for any resource for the next 40 years, but our analysis was fully inclusive of pricing possibilities much higher than today’s prices.

Not “Loud Enough”

Lastly, both letters claimed that our period of public comments was inadequate:

The BPW didn’t publicize these hearings loud enough.

The BPW timed the public comment period (Aug. 9- Sept. 9) to coincide with a time when many Holland citizens are away on vacation.

The month-long public comment period will soon come to an end on Sept. 9, preceded by an ill-scheduled set of public hearings on Tuesday and Wednesday.

Dismissing that we’ve been accepting public commenting through our websites, social media and public meetings for over a year, this particular period of public commenting has been advertised especially well. We have paid for newspaper advertising soliciting community input, asked for input through this website and on Facebook, and provided telephone numbers, email addresses and easy contact forms for sending input. We have scheduled public hearings for people to read their opinions into the public record and spent a month advertising and promoting the meetings.

We remain respectful of differing opinions as we try to make the most responsible decision for Holland’s energy future, but we won’t allow these types of misrepresentations to diminish the the hard work done by so many people in our community to make this an open, inclusive process.

Please don’t forget to attend the Formal Public Comment Hearings tonight and tomorrow from 5-7pm at the Holland DoubleTree Hotel.

The post Setting the Facts Straight from Letters to the Editor appeared first on Holland's Energy Future | P21 Decision.